Cosmology

Hubble Deep Field

Cosmology is the study of the Universe itself. Here, we will study the principles that we believe govern the way the universe behaves, based on observation and assumption. We will study the geometry of spacetime and gain understanding ot what we mean by curvature of spacetime. We will analyze the evidence that supports out theory, the cosmic microwave background radiation. We will also focus on what makes up the universe and how dark matter and dark energy play roles in the behavior of the universe.

Cosmological Principle

The cosmological principle is based on two observations and an assumption, that the universe is the same everywhere, it is the same in every direction, and that the laws of physics are the same everywhere.

 

  • Homeogeneous - the universe is the same everywhere
  • Isotropic - the same in every direction
  • The laws of physics are the same everywhere

 

The statement that the universe is homogeneous regards the universe on very large scales. If you look at the distribution of matter inside a galaxy and outside of a galaxy, the matter distribution is obviously not the same. If you look at the the Hubble Deep Field, it is easier to see what the cosmological principle means. A large expanse of the universe contains many galaxies. On an even larger scale, we see there are great clusters of galaxies with voids between. On an even larger scale, the pattern of clusters and voids begins to look like an overall pattern in the universe.

courderoy cloth

What is the difference between homogeneous and isotropic? If something is the same in every direction, isn't it also the same everywhere? This piece of corduroy is an example of something that is homogeneous but not isotropic. If you sample the corduroy anywhere, you see it is the same, but it is very different if you look upward, along the grain, or across the wales. Corduroy is not the same in every direction - it is not isotropic.

pencil-beam survey, described below
pencil-beam survey data graphed

 

A pencil-beam survey takes a lot of narrow-beamed samples of galaxies. The main takeaway here is that no matter what direction the beam survey is pointed, it sees roughly the same distribution of galaxies over space. It is tool which allows us to assess the isotropic nature of the universe on cosmological scales.

 

Our third point of the cosmological principle is that the laws of physics are the same everywhere. For instance, if we learn about the behaviors of subatomic particles by examining data from a particle accelerator like the Large Hadron Collider, we can infer what must have happened with particles at high energies like those that existed in the early stages of the universe, shortly after the big bang.

Mapping the universe

This image is the result of the first slice galaxy survey, mapping about 1000 galaxies over a wide field, using their redshifts to determine their distances away. The figure in the center was dubbed the "Stickman" by Margaret Geller upon its discovery. The body and arms of the Stickman are huge walls of galaxies. Notably, there are large bubble-like voids, stretching several million light years across. You could argue that on this scale, the universe does not look like it is the same everywhere (homogeneous).

Sloan Digital Sky Survey

The Sloan Digital Sky Survey was an even more extensive mapping of galaxies. The homogeneous nature of the universe becomes apparent with large enough sampling. The walls and voids tend to show up everywhere. If you sample big enough slices of the universe, it starts to look the same everywhere.

Recently, the Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS) was extended from the earlier 2-D slices into a fully 3-D survey to include four million galaxies and quasars between 2014 and 2020. The new, extended map also includes four types of galaxies: nearby galaxies, red galaxies, more distant star-forming galaxies and quasars. The SDSS provides information about the accelerated expansion of the universe by mapping the redshift pattern of the galaxies in 3-D space.

This video from the Extended Baryon Oscillation Spectroscopic Survey (eBOSS) describes the mapping mission and illustrates the 3-D map produced by the Sloan Digital Sky Survey, highlighting the spectral analysis of the galactic redshifts.

When was the universe born?

We can make a rough estimate of when the universe was born by considering Hubble's law. Remember, Hubble's law came about by recognizing that the farther away galaxies are, the higher their redshifts and the higher their recessional speeds. If we turn the clock backwards, the galaxies would all rush toward the same point. We can calculate how long it would take them to get to that point, by noticing that velocity = distance/time.

 

Time is distance/velocity. From Hubble's law, distance/velocity = 1/H0. We can get H0 experimentally, so we can calculate 1/H0. Using this method, we calculate the age of the universe to be about 14 billion years.

recessional velocity = H0 times distance; time = distance / velocity = distance / H0 times distance = 1/H0. time = 14 billion years

Where was the universe born?

Now we need to consider another question, where was the universe born? If we look out at the galaxies in the universe, they closest galaxies might be moving toward or away from us, but the faraway galaxies all seem to be moving away, and the farther they are, the faster they are moving away.

 

That's what it looks like from our Milky Way galaxy. What if we were in a galaxy very far away? Two main possibilities exist. The first is that the Milky Way is special, that it happens to lie at just the right place so that all of the galaxies are moving away from us. The second possibility is that we are not special. It would look like this from any other galaxy, that all of the other galaxies were moving away, the farther, the faster.

 

There is roughly a one in two hundred billion chance that we are special and happen to lie at the center of the universe. It is much more likely that the second possibility is true, that it would look like this to any galaxy.

 

Another way of resolving this question is to think back to the cosmological principle. If the universe is the same everywhere and in every direction, then nowhere is special. There is no center and no edge to the universe. Those would be "special" places.

More distant galaxies appear to move faster

This graphic illustrates that if two objects are farther apart on an expanding sphere, they move relatively faster.

 

Point A is 2 cm away at the start, and Point B is 1 cm away. After one second, the sphere has doubled in diameter. Point A has doubled its distance away and so has Point B.

 

Point A has moved at a speed of 1 cm/s and Point B has moved at a speed of 2 cm/s. The farther away any two dots start on this expanding sphere, the more they have moved apart between the first time and the second time.

 

The same is true of galaxies. As the universe expands, the farther a galaxy is away from us, the faster it appears to be moving. Notice that in our graphic, the dots themselves did not expand. Objects like planets, stars and galaxies do not expand as the universe expands, they just get farther apart.

no center no edge ---> the universe was not an explosion in an otherwise empty region the big bang involved the whole universe

Cosmological redshift

  • Cosmological redshift  is caused by expansion of  the universe
  • The motion involved is that of the universe expanding, not individual galaxies moving
  • Redshift measures how much the universe expanded since the light was emitted
    • Suppose light from a quasar has redshift = 5

 

      observed wavelength = 6x greater than at time of emission

      light was emitted when the universe was 1/6 present size

Expansion of the universe affects light differently than it does matter objects. When the universe expands, individual objects like planets, stars and galaxies do not expand, they just get farther apart. When light travels through expanding space, it does expand. The wavelength gets longer, so it is redshifted.

© Kathryn Hadley PhD 2020

recessional velocity = H0 times distance; time = distance / velocity = distance / H0 times distance = 1/H0. time = 14 billion years
Hubble Deep Field
Sloan Digital Sky Survey
no center no edge ---> the universe was not an explosion in an otherwise empty region the big bang involved the whole universe
courderoy cloth
pencil-beam survey, described below
pencil-beam survey data graphed
expanding sphere with dots
Hubble Deep Field
recessional velocity = H0 times distance; time = distance / velocity = distance / H0 times distance = 1/H0. time = 14 billion years
Sloan Digital Sky Survey
courderoy cloth
no center no edge ---> the universe was not an explosion in an otherwise empty region the big bang involved the whole universe
pencil-beam survey, described below
pencil-beam survey data graphed
expanding sphere with dots